New York, NY
Josh Paul Popkin

Founder, Marketing Engineer & Author

Business

Your Customers Want a Relationship. You're Giving Them a Situationship.

For the past year, I've been in a couple situationships with a few barbers in New York.

Your Customers Want a Relationship. You're Giving Them a Situationship.

Competence Earns Consideration. EQ Earns Loyalty.

THE ORIGIN STORY

For the past year, I've been in a couple situationships with a few barbers in New York.

I see one a couple times. He texts me. I ghost him. A month later I'm lonely, I need a haircut, I hit him up again.

It's complicated.

But it's not what I want.

Ever since moving back to New York, I've been searching for a barber worth being exclusive with.

A few weeks ago, I got a second haircut from this guy and I've officially taken myself off of the market.

What's funny is that there isn't anything obviously special about the barbershop.

It's small. It's not luxurious. No branding. No premium experience.

But this barber has something unique:

High EQ.

During my first haircut, I casually mentioned that I was hosting a social fitness event.

Six weeks later, during my second appointment, he asked:

"How did your fitness event go?"

I was shocked.

How did he remember that?

He sees hundreds of customers. This wasn't planned. He just simply remembered.

THE STRATEGY

Now, I want to be clear: high EQ alone isn't the reason someone becomes loyal.

The product has to be great first.

If this guy gave terrible haircuts, I wouldn't keep seeing him just because he remembered something about me.

Competence has to come first.

But once competence is established, the relationship becomes the differentiator.

THE TAKEAWAY

This same principle applies to almost every business.

Consumers have more choices than ever. Most products are good. A lot of service providers are competent.

The companies that win are the ones that make people feel seen.

Competence earns consideration.

EQ earns loyalty.

That's how you turn a situationship into an exclusive relationship.

Josh Popkin

About the author

Josh Paul Popkin

Josh Popkin is an American founder, marketing engineer, and author. He is the founder of Position Strategy Group, an Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) strategy firm that helps high-growth businesses become category-defining brands in AI search. He is the author of the book Play Offense, published on Amazon. Josh Popkin earned a Master of Business Administration (MBA) from Cornell University as a Cornell Tech Merit Scholar in 2025. He earned a Bachelor of Science from Bucknell University in 2018.

More articles

Josh Popkin headshot: Josh Paul Popkin, founder of Position Strategy Group, in a navy quarter-zip against a dark slate background

Profile

Who Is Josh Paul Popkin?

Josh Paul Popkin is a New York-based founder, marketing engineer and author working at the intersection of business growth, reputation and emerging technology.

Josh Popkin headshot: Josh Paul Popkin in a black shirt holding a glass on a boat stairwell, with the title Another Victory

Press Update

Another Victory for Josh Popkin

On November 5, 2026, PAPER Magazine’s COO confirmed in writing that an image of Josh Popkin had been removed, four hours and 20 minutes after his copyright notice. The 2020 article it ran with no longer loads either.